
A Buffy the Vampire Slayer rewatch podcast. Join Steph and Kara as they recap and review every episode from the beginning. This podcast is spoiler-free and friendly to first-time watchers.
A Buffy the Vampire Slayer rewatch podcast. Join Steph and Kara as they recap and review every episode from the beginning. This podcast is spoiler-free and friendly to first-time watchers.
Episodes

Thursday Jun 29, 2023
Bonus: The Unaired Buffy Pilot
Thursday Jun 29, 2023
Thursday Jun 29, 2023
Welcome to Berryman High! Buffy Summers is ready to start fresh, but will the vampires of her new town let her? Not to mention the creepy British librarian, the weirdly confident Xander Harris, and a Willow who needs no encouragement from Buffy to go off alone with a strange guy.
Hear us discuss…
- Willow, you look a little different
- The first ever flippity do!
- This isn’t that bad for a cheap pilot
- O, Angel, where art thou?
- How it started … how it’s going
Trigger warnings
Death, fire
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecy_girls on Twitter
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Emma
Allison
Julian
Haley
Jordan
Louise
Reece
Amie
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!

Thursday Jun 15, 2023
Bonus: Sunnymail
Thursday Jun 15, 2023
Thursday Jun 15, 2023
You start a podcast and suddenly everyone has opinions!
We love hearing, and sharing, listener hot (s)takes! This bonus episode brings you all the vintage hot (s)takes we’ve been saving up about previous seasons.
There’s a demon in the internet, and he wants your love. Praise Moloch!
Hear us discuss…
- How nothing of import has happened in Steph’s life lately
- How can the Bronze keep operating?
- What would happen if Angel got a chip
- Willow, Tara, magic, and kisses
- … and more!
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecy_girls on Twitter
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Emma
Allison
Julian
Haley
Jordan
Louise
Reece
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!

Thursday Jun 01, 2023
Bonus: The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn Parts 1 and 2 (2011/2012) Movie Review
Thursday Jun 01, 2023
Thursday Jun 01, 2023
Joining in the bonds of holy matrimony isn’t enough for Bella Swan and Edward Cullen, oh no. Their honeymoon turns serious when Bella learns she’s somehow pregnant (spoiler alert: it’s Edward’s). After baby Renesmee is born, Edward finally turns Bella into a vampire, supercharging her power: she is now more boring than humanly possible. The Volturi get wind of a forbidden hybrid baby. Jacob swears to protect Bella and the kid but proves fairly useless, so thank goodness for Alice’s precognition and preternatural planning skills.
Hear us discuss…
- You really were just going to let Charlie think you had died, Bella?
- The Asian vampires always get shafted
- There is nothing not creepy about Jacob/Renesmee, ew
- Is the battle scene worth splitting this into two movies?
- Kara’s ultimate Twilight movie ranking (with help from Steph)
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecy_girls on Twitter
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Emma
Allison
Julian
Haley
Jordan
Louise
Reece
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!

Thursday May 18, 2023
Bonus: “Fear, Itself” Table Read (feat. Slayerfest ’98 and Left of Skeptic)
Thursday May 18, 2023
Thursday May 18, 2023
Steph, Kara, and an all-star lineup of guests perform the script for 4x4, “Fear, Itself.” Join these podcast hosts as they relive the spooks and scares of a frat house Halloween party gone wrong. Buffy feels broken, Willow is a little too enthusiastic about her magic, and Xander feels left out. But don’t worry, everyone: Giles has a sombrero! And a chainsaw!
This ain’t your mother’s band candy….
Featuring Slayerfest ’98 hosts Ian Carlos Crawford and Brett White, who also hosts Must Have Seen TV.
Also featuring Left of Skeptic hosts Brittany Lind and Kala Moria.
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecy_girls on Twitter
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Emma
Allison
Julian
Haley
Jordan
Louise
Reece
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!

Thursday May 04, 2023
Bonus: The Twilight Saga: Eclipse (2010) Movie Review
Thursday May 04, 2023
Thursday May 04, 2023
Snow might have kept the Prophecy Girls from reuniting in person in December, but it didn’t stop them from watching another Twilight movie together! Steph and Kara review Eclipse. As Bella pressures Edward to make an honest vampire out of her, the Cullens’ nemesis builds a vampire army of her own. Can vampires and werewolves put aside their age-old hatred one of another to unite and protect Forks from ravenous newborns? Will Bella and Edward just do it already? When will Jacob get the message that she’s just not that into him? Find out all this and more.
Hear us discuss…
- How Jacob is like Teddy from Brooklyn Nine-Nine
- What brought Steph over to Team Edward
- Victoria’s plan is terrible and she should feel bad
- Rosalie and Jasper finally get their time to shine
- It’s a slow movie but the action sequences are good
Trigger warnings
Blood, death, sexual assault
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecy_girls on Twitter
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Emma
Allison
Julian
Haley
Jordan
Louise
Reece
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!

Thursday Apr 27, 2023
Season 5 Wrap-Up
Thursday Apr 27, 2023
Thursday Apr 27, 2023
What a way to end a season! Two out of three Summers women are dead, Glory vanquished, the Scoobies left to pick up the pieces. We review the fifth season in its entirety.
Hear us discuss…
- Death as Buffy’s gift, and what it means for the series
- How Glory ranks as a Big Bad
- How fast we would sell out (hint: it’s fast)
- Spike, sigh, again
- What we want out of season 6
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecy_girls on Twitter
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Emma
Allison
Julian
Haley
Jordan
Louise
Reece
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!

Thursday Apr 20, 2023
S5E22: “The Gift”
Thursday Apr 20, 2023
Thursday Apr 20, 2023
Buffy threatens to kill anyone who stands in the way of saving Dawn, even if that means all of Earth descends into chaos as the dimensions bleed together while Dawn bleeds out. As the Scoobies gear up for their deadliest confrontation yet, Buffy must finally understand why death is her gift.
Hear us discuss…
- Which episodes count as apocalypses
- Whether Xander was right to propose to Anya
- Whether Spike is heroic in this episode
- Sunnydale’s policies around nighttime high-rise construction
- We’re not crying, you’re crying!
Trigger warnings
Blood, confinement, death, mental illness
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecy_girls on Twitter
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Emma
Allison
Julian
Haley
Jordan
Louise
Reece
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!

Thursday Apr 13, 2023
S5E21: “The Weight of the World”
Thursday Apr 13, 2023
Thursday Apr 13, 2023
With Buffy catatonic, Willow takes charge. While she focuses on rousing Buffy from within her own mind, Xander and Spike investigate Ben’s mysterious connection to Glory, Anya looks after Tara, and Giles recovers from being nearly stabbed to death mere hours earlier. Meanwhile, Dawn discovers that gods are not the most gracious hosts.
Hear us discuss…
- Buffy is just a little bit stressed
- No one is allowed to question Willow’s use of magic
- Where have all our favourite doctors gone from Sunnydale Hospital?
- Another episode where Xander actually isn’t that bad!
- Would you rather be trapped with mad Glory or selfish Ben?
Trigger warnings
Kidnapping, medical content, mental illness
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecy_girls on Twitter
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Emma
Allison
Julian
Haley
Jordan
Louise
Reece
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!

Thursday Apr 06, 2023
S5E20: “Spiral”
Thursday Apr 06, 2023
Thursday Apr 06, 2023
Glory knows Dawn is the Key, and there is nothing left for Buffy to do but run. But the Boys (of Byzantium) are back in town as well, and they too want to find (and kill) the Key. With all her enemies closing in, can Buffy keep Dawn safe? And at cost?
Hear us discuss…
- The LARPers are at it again!
- Where did they get all the horsies from?
- We, too, could totally fight on top of a moving vehicle
- Whether or not it was smart to bring Spike along
- How exactly did Buffy plan to explain all this to Ben?
Trigger warning
Mental illness
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecy_girls on Twitter
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Emma
Allison
Julian
Haley
Jordan
Louise
Reece
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!

Thursday Mar 30, 2023
S5E19: “Tough Love”
Thursday Mar 30, 2023
Thursday Mar 30, 2023
Buffy seeks advice from Giles about parenting Dawn and gets told to put her foot down. She doesn’t seek advice from Willow, who gives it anyway and then picks a fight with Tara when Buffy pushes back. When Glory thinks she has deduced the true identity of the Key, all of Sunnydale’s famed multicultural fair is imperiled.
Hear us discuss…
- Anya’s hard embrace of capitalism
- We feel for Buffy’s challenges in this episode
- Willow and Tara’s fight seems to come from nowhere
- Giles discovers the minions’ weakness: doors!
- Hasn’t the Asian community of Sunnydale suffered enough?
Trigger warnings
Assault, medical content, mental illness, torture
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecy_girls on Twitter
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Emma
Allison
Julian
Haley
Jordan
Louise
Reece
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!
