Prophecy Girls: A Buffy Rewatch Podcast

S3E09: ”The Wish”

December 2, 2021

Cordelia is back and she’s over Xander Harris. So over him that she definitely isn’t pretending to kiss other boys or talking about him constantly. Eventually, she talks to the wrong (or right?) person, new girl Anya who shares Cordy’s love for designer labels but also happens to be a demon out to grant wishes of revenge. Cordelia’s wish that Buffy had never come to Sunnydale catapults her through the looking glass into a twisted version of her hometown … and Xander and Willow are still into each other! This girl cannot catch a break.


Hear us discuss…

  • So you’re just going to leave that demon corpse there?
  • We cannot with Xander’s revisionist history
  • All these actors are so old!
  • We are here for queer-coded vamp Willow
  • Steph is ready to be Asian Anya in the reboot CALL HER


Trigger warnings

Bullying, mechanical exsanguination, neck snapping, torture



✉ Email us at [email protected]

Join us on Discord:


We love hearing from our listeners!







Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!

Podbean App

Play this podcast on Podbean App