Prophecy Girls: A Buffy Rewatch Podcast

S2E19: “I Only Have Eyes for You”

September 2, 2021

Some supernatural force at Sunnydale High is forcing people to re-enact a deadly confrontation between a student and teacher from 1955. Giles is convinced this force is the spirit of dear departed Jenny Calendar. Buffy and the rest of the Scoobies aren’t convinced. Will they be able to put these troubled spirits to rest before any more lives are lost? Or will Angelus take his hands off Drusilla long enough to make good on his promise to get rid of the Slayer once and for all?


Hear us discuss…

  • How this episode deals so well with grief
  • Our first example of some group magic!
  • Steph has finally realized Angel and Dru are DOING IT
  • How many people in Sunnydale are in on the secret of the Hellmouth?
  • Spike should no longer be underestimated


Trigger warnings

Ableism, child abuse, death, gun violence, suicide, teacher–student relationship



✉ Email us at [email protected]


We love hearing from our listeners!

Podbean App

Play this podcast on Podbean App