A Buffy the Vampire Slayer rewatch podcast. Join Steph and Kara as they recap and review every episode from the beginning. This podcast is spoiler-free and friendly to first-time watchers.
Episodes
6 hours ago
6 hours ago
First, Angel’s obsession with giving baby Connor a good life might result in Fred losing her mind. Oh, and Lorne’s in danger too.
Then, business takes a back seat to pleasure as Angel drags the team to the ballet. Except for Lorne, of course, who gets left behind. But a possessive evil lurks beneath the surface of this production, and the only way to get to the bottom of it might be through Angel and Cordy getting to the bottom of each other.
Hear us discuss…
- Daddy Angel continues to deliver
- Angel, step away from Cordelia and the hair that is controlling her
- Lorne, honey, we need to talk about self-respect
- Fred and Gunn? That’s a yes from us
- Too slow, Wesley
Trigger warnings
Kidnapping, misogyny
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecygirls.ca on Bluesky
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!
Find Prophecy Girls merch at https://prophecygirls.ca/store
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Allison
Amie
Kristi
Kimmie
Laura
Katie
Clea
Julian
Thursday Jan 08, 2026
Thursday Jan 08, 2026
First, Angel defends his newborn son against all-comers. Enemies literally surround the hotel, and more gather on the horizon. Holtz seeks new allies in his revenge era. Lilah takes a page out of Wesley’s book and does RESEARCH.
Then, Cordelia is dying! Her latest vision lands her in a coma. The demon Skip shows up to insult her astral self and deliver the bad news, but he offers her a deal: she can Wishverse herself into a different reality, one where she’s a sitcom star instead of vision girl. But even that Cordy can’t avoid her destiny.
Hear us discuss…
- People feeling entitled to hold your baby
- Holtz’s reality TV show
- Lorne, please go somewhere you are valued
- The Powers That Be, being massive jerks? Shocking, really
Where is the fic about Doyle kissing Angel?
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecygirls.ca on Bluesky
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!
Find Prophecy Girls merch at https://prophecygirls.ca/store
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Allison
Amie
Kristi
Kimmie
Laura
Bahia
Katie
Clea
Julian
Thursday Jan 01, 2026
Thursday Jan 01, 2026
Angel is now Daddy.
Hear us discuss…
- The deliciousness of villains at each others’ throats
- Not his elevator, Angel nooooooo!
- Justice for Carrots and Lorne … again
- Why the birth of his son isn’t a moment of pure happiness for Angel
- Farewell to Darla … again
Trigger warnings
Labour, maternal mortality
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecygirls.ca on Bluesky
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!
Find Prophecy Girls merch at https://prophecygirls.ca/store
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Allison
Amie
Kristi
Kimmie
Laura
Bahia
Katie
Clea
Julian
Thursday Dec 25, 2025
Thursday Dec 25, 2025
First, the entire team at Angel Investigations is stunned when Darla turns up at their doorsteps, pregnant. Cordelia, salty that Angel would lie to her about sleeping with another blonde, quickly leaps to Darla’s aid. But Darla has cravings for more than mere pig’s blood.
Then, Darla goes into labour. Nobody saw this coming! (Except for that one guy.) Everyone in the underworld wants a piece of this miracle baby, including some, like Holtz, who have come a very long way indeed.
Hear us discuss…
- If it isn’t the consequences of Angel’s own actions!
- Steph’s thoughts as a mom on stranger danger at an arcade
- When did Wesley have time to go to med school?
- Wait, is Holtz actually a good guy?
- Shout-out to Colin, the OG prophesied vampire boy
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecygirls.ca on Bluesky
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!
Find Prophecy Girls merch at https://prophecygirls.ca/store
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Allison
Amie
Kristi
Kimmie
Laura
Bahia
Katie
Clea
Julian
Thursday Dec 18, 2025
Thursday Dec 18, 2025
First, Fred’s parents arrive in town. Instead of rejoicing at this reunion, Fred runs away. Tracking her down proves more challenging than expected, especially when the he-mantises show up.
Then, misogyny personified visits LA. No, not Spike. The fire cage man freed by Angel in “That Vision Thing” spreads sparkling misogyny among the menfolk, spurring Lilah and Cordelia to a common cause for once.
Hear us discuss…
- Poor Fred! She deserves time to unpack her trauma
- Fred’s parents are adorable and can stay as long as they want
- Lilah and Cordelia sharing a scene? Yay! Talking about a man? Boo!
- Kara has one or two things to say about “Billy”
- Finally a show that dares to prioritize men’s feelings over women’s
Trigger warnings
Misogyny, violence against women
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecygirls.ca on Bluesky
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!
Find Prophecy Girls merch at https://prophecygirls.ca/store
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Allison
Amie
Kristi
Kimmie
Laura
Bahia
Katie
Clea
Julian
Thursday Dec 11, 2025
Thursday Dec 11, 2025
First, the team’s investigation into unexplained demon slayings points them towards Gunn’s old crew. Gunn attempts to solve the case himself. However, a new guy on the block has other ideas, leading to a deadly confrontation in Carrots.
Then, a glimpse into Xander’s likely future when an old man body-swaps with Angel only to discover that he’s (gasp) a vampire! Trapped in the old man’s body, Angel faces his most difficult challenge yet: escape from a seniors’ home.
Hear us discuss…
- Gunn’s confusion about the mission is #relatable
- Steph has a new wish for who she’d be in the Buffyverse
- Poor Lorne. Justice for Carrots!
- Angel is so lucky Gunn brought burritos for breakfast
- Was this a shanshu?
Trigger warning
Gun violence
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecygirls.ca on Bluesky
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!
Find Prophecy Girls merch at https://prophecygirls.ca/store
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Allison
Amie
Kristi
Kimmie
Laura
Bahia
Katie
Clea
Julian
Thursday Dec 04, 2025
Thursday Dec 04, 2025
First, Angel returns from a grief sabbatical. When he kills a vampire from his past, her lover—also a vampire who used to roll with Angelus—swears revenge. Cordelia sees this as a great time to get Angel to talk about his feelings.
Then, Cordelia’s visions, which have been growing more and more painful, start to manifest as physical injuries to her body. Angel soon learns that Lilah has something to do with it, and if he wants her to stop, he’ll need to pay a steep price. Gavin does lawyer things.
Hear us discuss…
- Angel’s emotional growth and his response to grief
- The show is contractually obligated to let Davey B ride horsies
- Stand down, everyone! Cordelia’s hair is under control
- Wesley’s hair, however, is making Steph feel a way
- Justice for the old Chinese demon couple!
Trigger warnings
Body horror, disfigurement, torture
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecygirls.ca on Bluesky
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!
Find Prophecy Girls merch at https://prophecygirls.ca/store
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Allison
Amie
Kristi
Kimmie
Laura
Bahia
Katie
Clea
Julian
Thursday Nov 27, 2025
Thursday Nov 27, 2025
Sarah and Lea from Investigating Angel join Steph and Kara to discuss the original 1997 slasher fic starring Sarah Michelle Gellar; Freddie Prinze, Jr.; Jennifer Love Hewitt; and Ryan Phillipe.
Hear us discuss…
- How well the movie holds up
- SMG kinda steals the show
- The police in this town are deeply stupid
- OK, but we all agree these teens kind of deserved it, right?
- Connections to the 2025 sequel
Trigger warnings
Blood, dismemberment, murder, torture
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecygirls.ca on Bluesky
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!
Find Prophecy Girls merch at https://prophecygirls.ca/store
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Allison
Amie
Kristi
Kimmie
Laura
Katie
Clea
Thursday Sep 25, 2025
Thursday Sep 25, 2025
Steph and Kara reflect on Angel’s second year in LA. New office (twice), new team members, and new nemeses. An old flame returns, and the Dork Avenger rises.
Spoiler section for season 3 starts at 50:24.
Hear us discuss…
- Who is the love of Angel’s life and why is it Lindsey?
- Who is the Big Bad of season 2 and why is it Cordelia’s hair?
- Let the lawyers do lawyer things!
- We’re so happy Gunn isn’t a stereotype
- This is top tier commentary on what it means to be a hero
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecygirls.ca on Bluesky
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!
Find Prophecy Girls merch at https://prophecygirls.ca/store
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Allison
Amie
Kristi
Kimmie
Laura
Bahia
Katie
Clea
Julian
Thursday Sep 18, 2025
Thursday Sep 18, 2025
Now Queen of Pylea, Cordelia must attend to various royal duties, such as supervising the execution of her friend, or getting it on with the Groosalug. When a power-hungry priest decides it’s time to get rid of all cows, Wesley and Gunn must lead a revolt while also smelling revolting. Fred becomes an Angel whisperer.
Hear us discuss…
- Why did no one bring weapons to this dimension?
- Steph can replicate all the men’s expressions in this audio medium
- Wesley is getting more attractive by the episode
- How strong is Fred though?
- We’re shipping Groodelia!
Trigger warnings
Genocide, racism, slavery
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecygirls.ca on Bluesky
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!
Find Prophecy Girls merch at https://prophecygirls.ca/store
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Allison
Amie
Kristi
Kimmie
Laura
Bahia
Katie
Clea
Julian