A Buffy the Vampire Slayer rewatch podcast. Join Steph and Kara as they recap and review every episode from the beginning. This podcast is spoiler-free and friendly to first-time watchers.
Episodes
Thursday Sep 25, 2025
Thursday Sep 25, 2025
Steph and Kara reflect on Angel’s second year in LA. New office (twice), new team members, and new nemeses. An old flame returns, and the Dork Avenger rises.
Spoiler section for season 3 starts at 50:24.
Hear us discuss…
- Who is the love of Angel’s life and why is it Lindsey?
- Who is the Big Bad of season 2 and why is it Cordelia’s hair?
- Let the lawyers do lawyer things!
- We’re so happy Gunn isn’t a stereotype
- This is top tier commentary on what it means to be a hero
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecygirls.ca on Bluesky
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!
Find Prophecy Girls merch at https://prophecygirls.ca/store
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Allison
Amie
Kristi
Kimmie
Laura
Bahia
Katie
Clea
Julian
Thursday Sep 18, 2025
Thursday Sep 18, 2025
Now Queen of Pylea, Cordelia must attend to various royal duties, such as supervising the execution of her friend, or getting it on with the Groosalug. When a power-hungry priest decides it’s time to get rid of all cows, Wesley and Gunn must lead a revolt while also smelling revolting. Fred becomes an Angel whisperer.
Hear us discuss…
- Why did no one bring weapons to this dimension?
- Steph can replicate all the men’s expressions in this audio medium
- Wesley is getting more attractive by the episode
- How strong is Fred though?
- We’re shipping Groodelia!
Trigger warnings
Genocide, racism, slavery
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecygirls.ca on Bluesky
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!
Find Prophecy Girls merch at https://prophecygirls.ca/store
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Allison
Amie
Kristi
Kimmie
Laura
Bahia
Katie
Clea
Julian
Thursday Sep 11, 2025
Thursday Sep 11, 2025
First, Cordelia finds herself in a hostile dimension where she must work or die—so, not that different from LA. Desperate to get her back, Angel frets while Wesley does research and Gunn ponders where his responsibilities lie. Lorne decides it’s time to go home and bring the music.
Then, Queen C is back! But with great power comes great responsibility … to get down. Meanwhile, Wesley and Gunn lead a revolution, Lorne loses his head, and Angel meets a girl who loves him
Author Kendare Blake joins Steph and Kara again to help recap this episode! Check out her official trilogy of Buffy The Next Generation books!
Hear us discuss…
- New sexy evil lawyer just dropped!
- No one prepared for this road trip
- Angel discovers Spike was right all along
- So does Fred just carry bags of blood around or what
- Don’t aim for the horsies!
Trigger warnings
Enslavement, torture
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecygirls.ca on Bluesky
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!
Find Prophecy Girls merch at https://prophecygirls.ca/store
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Allison
Amie
Kristi
Kimmie
Laura
Bahia
Katie
Clea
Julian
Thursday Sep 04, 2025
Thursday Sep 04, 2025
First, a vision from the PTB sends the team in search of a man who stabbed himself in the eye. At Wolfram & Hart, Lindsey gets expensive whoosh surgery and receives a new hand. An evil hand! Lilah is not impressed, but Angel might be smitten.
Then, Cordelia has finally won a coveted role in a national commercial! But if the food poisoning or her truly horrible hair doesn’t derail her, Angel’s interference or her increasingly painful visions might. Meanwhile, a demon from Lorne’s home dimension wreaks havoc in LA until Angel goes hunting.
Hear us discuss…
- Should we bring back alarm clocks?
- Hear us out: Christian Kane and Tony Head singing in a cafe together
- Kara finally concedes this is a musical episode
- Steph reveals herself as a leading manosphere podcaster
- More Lorne lore? Yes please!
Trigger warnings
Ableism, body horror, kidnapping, misogyny, sexual harassment
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecygirls.ca on Bluesky
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!
Find Prophecy Girls merch at https://prophecygirls.ca/store
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Allison
Amie
Kristi
Kimmie
Laura
Bahia
Katie
Clea
Julian
Thursday Aug 28, 2025
Thursday Aug 28, 2025
A friend from Cordelia’s high school days shows up in Los Angeles, and she thinks Cordy looks scrumptious. Meanwhile, Angel has to adapt to working for Wesley and try to earn back Cordelia’s trust, but it’s a long road. If only someone could help him actualize his potential.
Special guest Ryan B. joins Steph and Kara for this episode! Follow him on TikTok and Instagram @ryanbtalkstv
Hear us discuss…
- Cordelia is always a real one
- Wesley’s gunshot wound healed with slayer speed
- Wolfram & Hart should have recruited Doug to turn Angel
- A pyramid scheme is the perfect place for Harmony actually
- Harmony, girl, we can’t stay mad at you and wish you all the best!
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecygirls.ca on Bluesky
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!
Find Prophecy Girls merch at https://prophecygirls.ca/store
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Allison
Amie
Kristi
Kimmie
Laura
Bahia
Katie
Clea
Julian
Thursday Aug 21, 2025
Thursday Aug 21, 2025
In what is most definitely the 16th and not the 18th episode of this season, Angel satisfies Darla thrice. Despite his dramatics, however, his happiness is far from perfect. Kate spirals, Lindsey flies off the handle, and Cordelia gets mystically impregnated (again).
Hear us discuss…
- How good Angel is in bed
- Lindsey being jealous of Angel’s performance in bed
- What exactly is Angel’s epiphany?
- Kate redemption arc UNcancelled??
- Yay, the band’s back together. Sort of.
Trigger warnings
Body horror, mystical pregnancy, sexual assault, suicide
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecygirls.ca on Bluesky
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!
Find Prophecy Girls merch at https://prophecygirls.ca/store
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Allison
Amie
Kristi
Kimmie
Laura
Bahia
Katie
Clea
Julian
Thursday Aug 14, 2025
Thursday Aug 14, 2025
First, zombie cop cuties stalk the streets of LA in navy blue booties. Wesley puts his life on the line daring them to lock him up and is shocked when they shoot him, a white man! While Gunn and Cordelia try to save his life and simultaneously defend Anne’s shelter, Angel relies on Kate to help him understand this new menace.
Then, when Angel learns of a 75-year review conducted by the Senior Partners that has all of Wolfram & Hart spooked, he sees it as an opportunity to take the fight to them. Darla has other ideas. Angel takes the elevator ride of his life, and what he learns leaves him shaken to his core, just in time for Darla to stir up his passions.
Coverage of “Reprise” starts at 54:45.
Hear us discuss…
- Wesley, when we said “check your white privilege,” this is not what we meant
- Kate redemption arc CANCELLED
- We love the Gunn split loyalties arc
- Somebody call Lagos; we found a second glove of Myneghon!!
- Poor Angel learning elevators don’t always solve his problems
Trigger warnings
Gun violence, police brutality, racism
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecygirls.ca on Bluesky
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!
Find Prophecy Girls merch at https://prophecygirls.ca/store
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Allison
Amie
Kristi
Kimmie
Laura
Bahia
Katie
Clea
Julian
Thursday Aug 07, 2025
Thursday Aug 07, 2025
First, Angel stalks another blonde from Sunnydale after discovering that Wolfram & Hart launders money through her youth shelter. When an old enemy tracks Angel down to LA, everything aligns for an epic con. Meanwhile, Cordelia, Wesley, and Gunn locate a new office.
Then, when physics graduate student’s experiment threatens to end the world, Angel and Lorne team up and go undercover on campus. It remains to be seen who’s the bigger enemy: the Six Flags demons who will stop at nothing to see this apocalypse happen, or the misogyny making it possible. Meanwhile, thanks to Virginia, the new Angel Investigations has its first case.
Coverage of “Happy Anniversary” starts at 43:50.
Hear us discuss…
- Anne is a delightful deep cut
- When will Lindsey and Lilah do lawyer things again??
- No one at this university cares about health and safety
- Gene should hang out with Jonathan
- Is Wesley … good at his job?
Trigger warnings
Misogyny, suicide
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecygirls.ca on Bluesky
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!
Find Prophecy Girls merch at https://prophecygirls.ca/store
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Allison
Amie
Kristi
Kimmie
Laura
Bahia
Katie
Clea
Julian
Thursday Jul 31, 2025
Thursday Jul 31, 2025
First, Drusilla reunites Darla with immortality over Angel’s strenuous objections and they go on a rampage. Wolfram & Hart’s lawyers watch with glee until they land in Darla’s chaotic sights. Wesley, Cordelia, and Gunn adjust to unemployment somewhere that is not this episode.
Then, the Dork Avenger RISES! Through montages and voiceovers, he makes the city safe again. He’s not ready. Then he’s ready. Then he’s not ready some more. Wesley, Cordelia, and Gunn get back in the action.
Coverage of “Redefinition” starts at 48:40.
Hear us discuss…
- Oh, suddenly you’re against massacres when you’re the victim?
- Whomst among us hasn’t sacrificed a basement full of lawyers?
- Kate redemption arc confirmed
- Lindsey and Angel, just kisssss already
- Can Angel ever top this Kool-Aid man entrance?
Trigger warnings
Mass death, neck snapping
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecygirls.ca on Bluesky
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!
Find Prophecy Girls merch at https://prophecygirls.ca/store
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Allison
Amie
Kristi
Kimmie
Laura
Bahia
Katie
Clea
Julian
Thursday Jul 24, 2025
Thursday Jul 24, 2025
First, Angel must use his power of disguise to infiltrate a demonic heist of a deadly artifact. Little does he know, Gunn is also on the case. Oh, and Kate’s there too. Yay.
Then, Darla discovers she is dying (again) and begs Angel to sire her. He refuses, so instead she karaokes, and the Host sends Angel on a wild goose chase supervised by an English butler. If he can endure three trials, he might just win back her life.
Coverage of “The Trial” starts at 50:00.
Hear us discuss…
- What makes a heist episode good
- Kate, ya boring
- Cordelia’s hair (again)
- Should Angel give Darla what she wants?
- Does this butler know Lloyd?
Trigger warnings
Neck snapping, terminal illness
💬 SOCIAL MEDIA:
- @prophecygirlspodcast on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok
- @prophecygirls.ca on Bluesky
- prophecygirls.ca
✉ Email us at prophecygirlspodcast@gmail.com
Join us on Discord: https://prophecygirls.ca/discord
We love hearing from our listeners!
Support Prophecy Girls on Buy Me a Coffee!
Find Prophecy Girls merch at https://prophecygirls.ca/store
🎬 PRODUCERS:
Allison
Amie
Kristi
Kimmie
Laura
Bahia
Katie
Clea
Julian